Despite modernized career personnel tools put in place by the U.S. Army, soldiers in the U.S. Army Reserve would benefit from a more personal approach, with more direct career development discussions.

While active-duty soldiers rotate through assignments and benefit from robust talent management systems, traditional Reserve soldiers, particularly those in Troop Program Units, frequently promote within a single geographic area and remain in place for extended periods.

Sometimes called homesteading, a widespread but often unaddressed pattern of allowing soldiers to remain in one location for an extended period, it erodes professional growth, delays promotion eligibility, and undermines unit readiness. That it exists and continues unchecked can have a huge cost for the Army Reserve. 

Modern personnel systems, such as the Integrated Personnel and Pay System-Army, known as IPPS-A, have improved visibility into vacancies and career preferences. However, the technology alone is insufficient.

Lacking dedicated mentorship, many soldiers remain unaware of growth opportunities beyond their mileage preferences or local units. The Army Reserve’s reliance on administrative structures like regional readiness divisions often fails to support proactive talent development. As a result, unfilled vacancies persist, and soldiers’ careers stagnate.

Career Advancement

If a soldier is limited in exposure to diverse assignments, it reduces operational effectiveness. A combat medic may spend years assigned to a headquarters element, unaware of more developmental positions in nearby field hospitals. Without structured guidance, soldiers often miss chances to expand their skills through broadening assignments such as drill sergeant duty, instructor roles or inspector general positions. These experiences are essential to career advancement.

Although IPPS-A allows soldiers to update preferences and search for assignments, many remain locked into a 50-mile radius from their home of record unless they intentionally opt out. In the absence of personalized guidance, many soldiers fail to update their preferences. They may remain in immaterial or nonpromotable positions, which prematurely caps their progression.

Combat arms veterans entering the Reserve are especially vulnerable. Transitioning into sustainment-heavy formations, they frequently lack access to counseling that could guide them into promotable specialties. Without a new MOS or broadening assignments, these soldiers often face limited advancement. Professional military education slots tend to favor operational career fields, further compounding the challenge.

Officers, though supported by branch managers, encounter similar issues. The quality and breadth of career advice can vary widely. Limited access to promotion timelines or career path insights can delay a soldier’s development or result in missed opportunities.

A Reserve paralegal sergeant with multiple deployments shared that when soldiers remain in stagnant roles for years without rotational exposure, they often miss the chance to gain cross-echelon experience. She said this lack of experience directly delays legal processing timelines during deployments, affecting unit-level mission success. This observation underscores how the absence of structured mentorship or career movement can create real-world performance gaps.

Force Multiplier

Solving this challenge requires more than systems, it requires people. Leaders can leverage career counselors already present in formations to support strategic talent development. By expanding their scope from retention-centric to career development, they become a force multiplier.

Many counselors focus narrowly on Individual Ready Reserve (IRR) outreach and reenlistments. Refocusing them to advise on professional military education planning, assignment mobility and MOS transitions unlocks meaningful impact. Soldiers from promotable specialists to sergeant first class, and second lieutenant to major benefit from tailored guidance that aligns individual goals with organizational needs.

IPPS-A allows soldiers to manage preferences and view vacancies, but engagement remains inconsistent. Counselors can guide soldiers through updating mileage settings, interpreting vacancy maps and tracking promotable timelines. This personalized support ensures that soldiers take full advantage of digital systems.

The Selected Reserve Incentive Program offers broad eligibility for bonuses and travel reimbursements across formations. Many soldiers remain unaware of these benefits. Counselors must actively educate soldiers on these options to help remove perceived financial barriers to reassignment.

Mentorship, Development

Structured one-on-one sessions and targeted workshops help soldiers visualize a long-term career trajectory. By tracking billet tenure and offering course corrections early, counselors reduce stagnation and increase reenlistment likelihood. This model builds a culture of ownership and reinforces the Reserve’s commitment to mentorship and soldier development.

The Army Reserve has an opportunity to implement this solution with minimal disruption. Leaders can expand existing career counselor roles by updating policy guidance, limiting the effect on already constrained budgets. Higher-echelon career managers must actively participate in regional readiness division slating processes to ensure assignment decisions align with both soldier potential and operational requirements.

Empowered career counselors would track billet tenure and proactively engage soldiers who remain in the same position for more than four years. They would serve as early warning systems for stagnation, offering alternatives and highlighting lateral or upward movement paths that might otherwise go unnoticed.

This engagement boosts retention by reinforcing the Army’s investment in each soldier’s long-term success.

At the unit level, this approach would relieve command teams of the unrealistic burden of tracking career pathways across every MOS and area of concentration. Leaders can focus on readiness, confident that their soldiers are receiving tailored guidance from trained professionals.

More importantly, soldiers gain a clearer sense of ownership over their professional development. When properly advised, they are more likely to seek diverse experiences, build broader competencies and stay committed to the force. Career satisfaction improves, as does the Army Reserve’s overall readiness posture.

Train and Implement

A supplemental module would complete the necessary preparation. It should include vacancy analysis, planning for professional military education timing and guidance on using IPPS-A to update career profiles and interpret assignment data. Additionally, counselors must understand Selected Reserve Incentive Program updates so they can inform soldiers about available bonuses and travel benefits.

This training must ensure counselors can assist soldiers in interpreting digital tools, updating career profiles and aligning assignments with long-term goals. Soldiers unfamiliar with these systems need active guidance to make informed decisions, especially when career-altering deadlines or eligibility windows are involved.

One junior combat medic returned from deployment and expressed interest in expanding into medical logistics. However, he found no career mapping or support within his headquarters element and ultimately left the Reserve at the end of his contract. He later shared that with structured guidance and career planning, he would have stayed.

Explain Programs

Counselors must explain the changes outlined in the Selected Reserve Incentive Program. Many soldiers remain unaware that travel incentives and bonuses are now available for a broader range of unit types and duty locations. With this knowledge, soldiers can evaluate assignments more holistically and make decisions that align personal development with family and financial considerations.

Workshops and one-on-one sessions with counselors can institutionalize these practices across formations. This creates a professional culture in which career planning and mentorship are ongoing processes, not just reactions to upcoming boards or promotion cycles. When soldiers understand how to track and control their progression, they contribute more effectively to their units and stay better aligned with Army priorities.

Traditional soldiers in the Reserve need structured career pathways that match the complexity of today’s missions. By empowering career counselors as strategic advisers, the Reserve can reduce stagnation, close talent gaps and improve readiness without major cost. While tools like IPPS-A enhance transparency, soldiers still require personalized guidance to navigate their careers effectively. This human-centered approach strengthens retention, builds more capable formations and ensures the Reserve remains prepared for future operational demands.

If the Reserve doesn’t prioritize proactive career management, it risks more than delayed promotions; it risks losing the long-term trust and commitment of its soldiers.

* * *

Command Sgt. Maj. Blake Hudson, U.S. Army Reserve, is the command sergeant major of the 424th Multifunctional Medical Battalion, Newtown, Pennsylvania. A recent graduate of the Sergeants Major Academy, Fort Bliss, Texas, he was previously the senior enlisted adviser, Office of the Inspector General, U.S. Army Reserve 3rd Medical Command (Deployment Support).  He is completing two bachelor’s degrees: one in interdisciplinary studies from Liberty University, Virginia, and one in leader and workforce development from the U.S. Army Command and General Staff College.